top of page
Featured Posts

Evaluation, Inspection, Audit: Is there a difference?

While working with various development organisations over the years, I realise that sometimes the term ‘evaluation’ is sometimes used rather loosely. For example, the staff of an organisation visit the office of an implementing partner, tour of the project site, speak to the beneficiaries/recipients and then write an ‘evaluation’ report. However, was it really an evaluation that was undertaken? Or was it an inspection? Or an audit? I find that these terms sometimes causes confusion and hopefully this article can shed light on the matter.


Evaluations are:

  • the systematic and objective assessment of an ongoing or completed project, programme or policy, its design, implementation and results. Evaluations usually employ a rigorous methodology (or evaluation method, for example Most Significant Change or Appreciative Inquiry).


Evaluations are now commonplace in life (and death!)



Inspection tends to be:

  • a general examination of an organisational unit, issue or practice to ascertain the extent it adheres to normative standards and good practices.

  • done to make recommendations for improvement or corrective action.

  • performed when there is a perceived risk of non-compliance primarily for project management.


Audit tends to be:


• an assessment of the adequacy of management controls to ensure economical and efficient use of resources, the safeguarding of assets; the reliability of financial and other information; the compliance with regulations, rules and established policies; the effectiveness of risk management; and the adequacy of organizational structures, systems and processes.


• focused on compliance while evaluation is more closely linked to learning and development.



Reviews tend to be:


• distinct from evaluations and more closely associated with monitoring.

• periodic or ad hoc, often light assessments of the performance of an initiative and do not apply the due process of evaluation or rigour in methodology.

• emphasize operational issues.

• Unlike evaluations conducted by independent evaluators, reviews are often conducted by those internal to the commissioning organisation.


Research tends to be:

• a systematic examination completed to develop or contribute to knowledge of a particular topic.

• can often feed information into evaluations and other assessments.


Understanding the objectives of an investigation can help an organisation to determine whether an inspection, an audit, an evaluation or a review is needed. Subsequently the appropriate reporting templates may be developed to capture the findings from these investigations.


To cite the example at the start of this article, 7 out of 10 times these periodic monitoring visits are really a review instead of an audit. As such, if we were to get technical, the document with the findings from this visit should read ‘Review’ (or something similar) but not ‘Evaluation’.


It may seem like a minor thing, but I have seen in the past where the inability to distinguish (and communicate!) the different types of investigations led to serious misunderstanding and resistance among project staff. There are times when the staff really believed that a routine monitoring visit undertaken for the purposes of a review, was an inspection. Likewise persons may make certain decisions about the programme or project without realizing the site visit failed to have the rigor of an actual evaluation.


Thanks for reading!


3 Comments


MZKO QPFQ
MZKO QPFQ
Dec 24, 2024

代发外链 提权重点击找我;

google留痕 google留痕;

Fortune Tiger Fortune Tiger;

Fortune Tiger Fortune Tiger;

Fortune Tiger Slots Fortune…

站群/ 站群;

万事达U卡办理 万事达U卡办理;

VISA银联U卡办理 VISA银联U卡办理;

U卡办理 U卡办理;

万事达U卡办理 万事达U卡办理;

VISA银联U卡办理 VISA银联U卡办理;

U卡办理 U卡办理;

온라인 슬롯 온라인 슬롯;

온라인카지노 온라인카지노;

바카라사이트 바카라사이트;

EPS Machine EPS Machine;

EPS Machine EPS Machine;

EPS Machine EPS Machine;

Like

MZKO QPFQ
MZKO QPFQ
Dec 17, 2024

무료카지노 무료카지노;

무료카지노 무료카지노;

google 优化 seo技术+jingcheng-seo.com+秒收录;

Fortune Tiger Fortune Tiger;

Fortune Tiger Fortune Tiger;

Fortune Tiger Slots Fortune…

站群/ 站群

gamesimes gamesimes;

03topgame 03topgame

EPS Machine EPS Cutting…

EPS Machine EPS and…

EPP Machine EPP Shape…

Fortune Tiger Fortune Tiger;

EPS Machine EPS and…

betwin betwin;

777 777;

slots slots;

Fortune Tiger Fortune Tiger;

Like

XTGY TPTQ
XTGY TPTQ
Nov 11, 2024

EPS Machine EPS Cutting…

EPS Machine Eps Raw…

EPS Machine EPS Recycling…

EPS Machine EPS Mould;

EPS Machine EPS Block…

EPP Machine EPP Shape…

EPTU Machine ETPU Moulding…

EPS Machine Aging Silo…

EPTU Machine ETPU Moulding…

EPS Machine EPS and…

EPS Machine EPS and…

AEON MINING AEON MINING

AEON MINING AEON MINING

KSD Miner KSD Miner

KSD Miner KSD Miner

BCH Miner BCH Miner

BCH Miner BCH Miner

Like
Recent Posts
Search By Tags

​​​Ann-Murray Brown

Monitoring, Evaluation and
Facilitation
  • Facebook Clean Grey
  • Twitter Clean Grey
  • Google+ Clean Grey
  • LinkedIn Clean Grey
bottom of page